Fifteen years ago, Catherine (Marg Helgenberger) helped put John Mathers (Victor Bevine) on death row for the rape and murder of a coed at a nearby college. Her body was dumped in a trash bag, and two other girls found the same way were also linked to the
Number of Votes:
as David PhillipsEric Szmanda
as Greg SandersGary Dourdan
as Warrick BrownGeorge Eads
as Nick StokesJorja Fox
as Sara SidleMarg Helgenberger
as Catherine WillowsPaul Guilfoyle
as Jim BrassRobert David Hall
as Dr. Al RobbinsWilliam Petersen
as Gil Grissom
as Jacqui Franco
as Sally RothDavid Lee Smith
as Cody LewisJohn Goodwin
as PsychiatristMichael Chieffo
as Tom RothNikke Danielle Moore
as Phe Caplan
as Charlene RothVictor Bevine
as John MathersViola Davis
as Ms. CampbellWade Williams
as Mr. RestonWayne Pere
Margmad 03 June 2003
This was a great episode! And every time I try to write a review, something goes wrong, so I'll keep it short and simple! Catherine basically put an innocent man on death row - twice! The second time he died tough, and she felt guilty! And Grissom was in his element when he found some bugs to gaze out for a few hours - as Cath's my fave character, I loved every second of this!
babydoll 12 July 2003
I loved this episode! As I said, a case from 15 years ago haunts Catherine as John Mathers, who was due to be excecuted, survived literally by the skin of his teeth, although he did commit crimes, he was the copycat, and the real killer's still out there!
supercybergeek 06 April 2004
awesome, can't wait to see the continuation. I love the to be continued episodes, but I hate the face that you never know when it's gonna come. I hate it!
marghelgenberger 18 April 2004
I love catherine's character, so I love this episode with her as the centrum!!!
simonkilford 12 July 2004
this episode was good
weeping willow 20 June 2004
this is also another close home hit for cath because now shes never going to liv it dwn
jimjam 08 August 2004
excellent episode although having taped it onlate night telly i have no idea when the coninuation is and whodunnit???
ILOVEMARG 13 August 2004
This episode was brilliant, marg rocks!!!!
FoxRox 08 August 2004
It would have been more interesting if the guy they almost- executed had been innocent.
2ms.mnm22 10 September 2004
This Episode was wonderful. MH is my Fav. Character. I Love This Show!
iluvnick 31 October 2004
Another average episode. Catherine is awesome.
sns 10 September 2004
I love this episode and I wish that the rating was higher up on this list. It had good dramatic quality and great display of emotions. I love this episode and probably can stand a few reruns without getting tired of it.
i_luv_greg_and_ryan2449 07 February 2005
showhat 31 March 2005
well jhust makes you think what kinda sick twisted freaks there are out there doesn't it?WHO DID IT????????????????????
James Corck 23 March 2005
Interesting never ending chapter with twists once and again. Makes you think all the time...or maybe can make you change of channel.
Silver 186 19 April 2005
This episode was great!!! I loved it, I liked how everyone was acting, and how Grissom at the end was freaked out. The whole episode was rather creepy, I thought the guy that they showed as the killer looked a lot Nigel Crane.
CSI-Ballistics 12 May 2005
The whole method of the killer was great. The fact that the person Catharine put away wasn't the real killer but still a murderer was a nice touch. Ladies, bring wet-naps with you wherever you go lol.
crazybec 30 November 2005
really really great episode....loved Grissom at the end-"It makes me very uncofortable to realise this guy is smarter than me."
csi_roxsmyworld 09 January 2007
okok..i kno i cheat..i havent seen this one yet...but it sounds weird...yet scary! i didnt start to LOVE this show until like last year whn my mom started to watch it..yall prob hate me for it:)
csilvr2460 05 February 2006
leggo_my_greggo 30 January 2007
ok so they were gonna kill this guy...but save him?? so weird n confusing...and how the two girls both died the same way